at:nngress nf ifre lftnite~ ~fates 1Wla.sqington, il<!r 20515 197 March 21, 2018 The Honorable Ajit V. Pai Chairman Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street SW Washington, DC 20554 Dear Chairman Pai: We urge you to abandon your plan to drastically cut back the congressionally-mandated Lifeline program that has successfully provided phone and internet services when people cannot afford them. We ask that you reconsider your plan to take this critical program away from 8.3 million struggling Americans. The Lifeline Program is essential for millions of Americans who use their devices to find jobs, to schedule doctor's appointments, to complete their school assignments, to interface with the government, or to stay in touch with their loved ones. The program helps Americans- including disproportionate numbers of veterans and people of color-help themselves. The FCC recently proposed to exclude the majority of carriers from participating in the program and to arbitrarily cap the fund. While you have stated that you are aiming to curb waste, fraud, and abuse, experts have repeatedly testified that the sorts of measures you are proposing do not have a successful track record. Instead, these approaches merely force millions of otherwise qualified people to lose service. These measures could be especially brutal during periods of economic downturn when people need the most help. If you are truly concerned about waste, fraud, and abuse, the Commission should work to accelerate the rollout of the National Verifier that would ensure centralized oversight of the program. Unlike your approach, the National Verifier has received widespread and bipartisan support. In fact, the Government Accountability Office has testified that the National Verifier will resolve most issues that may remain with the program without the same brutal side effects on low-income communities. Remarkably, among the comments filed by key stakeholders on the docket, we are not aware of any that fully embrace the Chairman's proposal, and most urge substantial revision if not outright abandonment of the proceeding. We therefore ask that you abandon this proceeding cutting the Lifeline program, and instead move forward with a full implementation of the 2016 reforms, including the expedition of the National Verifier. Policymakers at all levels of government are united in their desire to close the PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER digital divide, but the last thing we should be doing is rolling back the policies that have brought connectivity to millions of Americans. This proposal is untimely, counterproductive, and actively undermines our shared goal of connecting everyone. Sincerely, <f1~~ ,2 · c.Q~ Member of Congress ~~-B_f)_ar-~-g~· n,_~--~------ Do a . Beyer, Jr. Member of Congress Member of Congress ~ ~J~·~ qv. Sanford~ Bishop, Jr. Earl Blumenauer Member of Congress Member of Congress Member of Congress ~Michael E. Capuano ~.~~ Member of Congress Member of Congress Judy Chu Steve Cohen Member of Congress Member of Congress Jim Cost Member of Congress Diana DeGette Member of Congress Member of Congress ~c__ _ " John Delaney Mark DeSaulnier Member of Congress Member of Congress ~ank'~ Member of Congress Member of Congress Robin L. Kelly ~. a{_ __ Member of Congress Member of Congress ~~-4"-4 Ted Lieu Member of Congress Member of Congress Ben Ray Lujan Member of Congress Doris Matsui Member of Congress Mike Doyle Member of Congre Member of Congress ~~~-r: :::::::==~-=--- -- Eliot L. Engel Adriano Espaillat Member of Congress Member of Congress Member of Congress Member of Congress v Luis Gutierrez Member of Congress Member of Congress Colleen Hanabus Member of Cong ess Betty Mc o lum Member of Congress ce Meng mber of Congress ace F. Napolitano ember of Congress ~'- Eleanor Holmes Norton Member of Congress Member of Congress MarkPocan Member of Congress Cedric L. Richmond ~, ~·di~ Member of Congress Member of Congress Member of Congress Member of Congress Gregorio Kilili CarG'°acho Sablan Member of Congress \ Robert~tt Member of Congress Member of Congress Terri A. Sewell Member of Congress Carol Shea-Porter Member of Congress Member of Congress Dina Titus Paul Tonka Member of Congress Member of Congress Nydia M. Velazquez Member of Congress Member of Congress ~WdvL- Peter Welch Member of Congress Member of Congress